The Chilling Tale of Ronald Defeo and the Amityville Voices

The Amityville Horror is a chilling tale of the supernatural, but what happened in reality?

In November 1974, Ronald Defeo Jr. murdered his entire family in their home at 112 Ocean Avenue, and it soon became known as the site of The Amityville Horror.

But what about the voices said to be heard within these walls? Was there any truth behind this mysterious story, or was it just an elaborate hoax?

Through investigations into Ronald Defeo Jr.’s motives and scientific evidence for the existence of paranormal activity, we can finally uncover if there is any truth to this terrifying legend surrounding Ronald DeFeo and The Amityville Voices.

Table of Contents:

The Amityville Horror

The Defeo Family Tragedy

On November 13th, 1974, six members of the DeFeo family were brutally murdered in their home at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, New York.

The eldest son Ronald DeFeo Jr. was convicted of the murders and sentenced to life imprisonment without parole. He claimed that he heard voices telling him to kill his family, and it has been speculated that this may have been a form of mental illness or demonic possession.

The Lutz Family’s Experiences

In December 1975, George and Kathy Lutz moved into the house with their three children. They reported strange occurrences such as levitating beds, cold spots in certain rooms, swarms of flies despite winter weather conditions outside, and disembodied voices speaking to them throughout the night.

After 28 days, they fled from the house, never to return, claiming that they had experienced supernatural forces within its walls.

Numerous paranormal investigators have visited 112 Ocean Avenue, including Ed and Lorraine Warren.

They concluded that an evil force was present in the house, which could be responsible for all the strange events within its walls.

Many still believe something sinister lurks within those four walls, waiting for another unsuspecting victim.

The Amityville Horror is a chilling tale of tragedy and terror that has captivated audiences for decades. Now, let’s take a closer look at the Ronald Defeo case, and the mysterious voices heard in Amityville.

Ronald Defeo Jr. and His Motives

Ronald Defeo Jr. was born in 1951 to Louis and Louise Defeo, a middle-class family living in Amityville, New York. Ronald had five siblings and lived together in a Dutch Colonial house on Ocean Avenue.

Despite his seemingly normal upbringing, Ronald struggled with mental health issues early on.

Early Life of Ronald Defeo Jr.: As a child, Ronald was often seen as complex and disruptive by his teachers and peers alike.

He had difficulty controlling his emotions, leading to frequent outbursts of anger that sometimes escalated into physical violence against other students or adults around him.

By the time he reached high school, he had become increasingly isolated from those around him due to his behavior and lack of social skills.

The Night of the Murders: On November 13th, 1974, at approximately 3:15 am, 23-year-old Ronald entered his home with two rifles and proceeded to shoot each member of his family while they were sleeping in their beds one by one until all six members were dead – including himself as the last victim before fleeing the scene shortly after 4 am.

It is believed that this mass murder was motivated by financial gain since it occurred just days after Louis Defeo Sr., who owned several businesses, including a car dealership, had taken out life insurance policies for each family member totaling over $200 000 dollars.

After being arrested later that day at 2 pm, Ronald was charged with six counts of second-degree murder for killing his parents and four siblings.

During the trial proceedings, defense attorneys argued that Ron had a severe mental illness, which caused him to believe he heard voices telling him to kill.

However, prosecutors argued premeditation, citing evidence that Ron had disabled all phones within reach before entering the home, indicating intent.

In March 1975, Ron was found guilty on all charges resulting in 25 years imprisonment without parole; however, this sentence was reduced twice due to legal technicalities, eventually leading to his release in 1996 despite still denying involvement in the murders throughout his incarceration period.

Ronald Defeo Jr.’s motives for the horrific murders of his family remain a mystery to this day. As we continue exploring the Amityville case, let us now turn our attention to the strange voices that haunt the house and its occupants.

Key Takeaway: Ronald Defeo Jr. was convicted of murdering his entire family in 1974 and sentenced to 25 years imprisonment without parole. Although defense attorneys argued that he had a mental illness, prosecutors cited evidence of premeditation leading to his conviction. Despite denying involvement throughout his incarceration, Ron was released in 1996 due to legal technicalities.

The Voices in Amityville

Witness Accounts of the Voices

The most widely reported witness accounts of strange voices heard in the Amityville house come from George and Kathy Lutz, who moved into the home shortly after Ronald Defeo Jr.’s murders.

According to their reports, they heard various disembodied voices coming from different parts of the house at all hours of the day and night. They also claimed that these voices aggressively spoke to them, often using profanity or threatening language.

Explanations for the Voices

Many paranormal investigators believe these mysterious voices could be evidence of some supernatural activity occurring within the walls of 112 Ocean Avenue.

Some have suggested that it may be evidence of residual energy left behind by Ronald Defeo Jr. In contrast, others have theorized that it could be caused by demonic entities or other spirits lingering in the home due to its violent history.

Psychological Explanations for The Voices

On the other hand, many skeptics point out that there is no scientific proof to support any claims about supernatural activity at Amityville. Instead, they suggest that what George and Kathy experienced was a product of their imaginations or heightened emotions due to living in such a notorious location with such a tragic past.

Psychologists have suggested that this type of phenomenon can occur when people are under extreme stress or fear, causing them to experience auditory hallucinations, manifesting as “voices” speaking directly inside their heads.

The mysterious voices in Amityville remain a source of fascination and speculation, with many believing that they are evidence of the supernatural. Next, we will examine the psychological implications of Ronald Defeo’s actions leading to the murders.

Key Takeaway: The mysterious voices heard in the Amityville house has been attributed to various explanations, from supernatural activity to psychological phenomena. While paranormal investigators believe these voices could be evidence of some otherworldly presence, skeptics suggest that they are simply products of fear and stress caused by living in such a notorious location with such a tragic past.

The Aftermath of Amityville

The story of the Defeo family tragedy and subsequent haunting at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, New York, became a media sensation. In 1977, Jay Anson published his book “The Amityville Horror,” which was later adapted into a film starring James Brolin and Margot Kidder.

This led to numerous other books and films being released over the years about the house on Ocean Avenue.

Public Perception of Amityville: Public perception of the events in Amityville has been primarily shaped by these various adaptations.

Many believe what happened in the house is true, while others remain skeptical due to a lack of evidence or inconsistencies between accounts from different sources. Some have even gone as far as to suggest that Ronald Defeo Jr., convicted for murdering his family members, may have been innocent and framed for crimes he did not commit.

The Amityville Horror has had a lasting impact on popular culture since its release over 40 years ago. It has inspired numerous imitators, some based on real-life events like those in Long Island and others purely fictional tales meant to scare audiences around Halloween time each year.

Despite its controversial nature, the legacy of this infamous case will likely remain for many years as it continues to fascinate people with its mysterious elements and unanswered questions that have persisted all these decades.

The Amityville case has had a lasting impact on the public, media, and culture, leaving many to wonder what happened that fateful night in 1974. Next, we will examine Ronald Defeo’s life after the events of Amityville and how his story has been portrayed in popular culture.

Is There Any Truth to the Story?

The Amityville Horror has been a source of fascination for many years. In 1975, Ronald Defeo Jr. brutally murdered his entire family in their home in Amityville, New York.

This event sparked numerous investigations into the events leading to and following the murders. Many people have speculated that supernatural forces were at work, but no definitive proof has ever been found to support this claim.

Scientific Evidence for the Story: While no scientific evidence proves any paranormal activity occurred during or after the murders, some researchers believe certain aspects of the story may be true.

For example, witnesses reported hearing strange voices from inside and outside the house shortly before and after Defeo’s crime was committed.

Some experts suggest these could have been hallucinations caused by extreme stress or fear rather than actual ghosts or spirits communicating with those present during the tragedy.

In conclusion, despite decades of speculation about the events that occurred in Amityville on November 13th, 1974, it is unlikely that we will ever know if there was any truth behind The Amityville Horror story.

This mystery continues to captivate people today as much as it did when it first made headlines over forty years ago. Its shroud of doubt and intrigue remains intact.

The story of Ronald Defeo And The Amityville Voices is complex and has many layers. Investigations, scientific evidence, and personal accounts provide insight into this mysterious event’s truth. Next, we will explore how these events impacted those involved in the tragedy.

FAQs About Ronald Defeo and the Amityville Voices

Is Ronald Joseph Defeo Jr still alive?

No, Ronald Joseph Defeo Jr is not still alive. He was convicted of the 1974 Amityville murders and sentenced to six consecutive sentences of 25 years to life in prison.

He has been incarcerated since 1975 and remains in jail today. His current age is 66, making it impossible for him to be alive outside of prison walls.

What did Ron DeFeo Jr die of?

Ron DeFeo Jr. died of multiple gunshot wounds on November 13th, 1974.

He was found dead in his home in Amityville, New York, after shooting and killing six family members with a rifle.

The cause of death was ruled as homicide by the Suffolk County Medical Examiner’s Office. His father, Ronald DeFeo Sr., later confessed to the crime and was convicted in 1975.

Who played Ronald Defeo Jr?

Ronald DeFeo Jr. was the perpetrator of the 1974 Amityville murders, in which he killed six family members at their home in Amityville, New York.

He was tried and convicted of second-degree murder for each victim and sentenced to 25 years to life in prison. Ronald DeFeo Jr., now 64 years old, is serving his sentence at Sullivan Correctional Facility in Fallsburg, New York.

Did the Amityville house have a pool?

Yes, the Amityville house did have a pool. It was located in the backyard and was surrounded by trees and shrubs for privacy.

The pool was built shortly after the Lutz family moved into the home in 1975. It is believed that George Lutz had it installed to help his children cope with their fear of being inside the house due to its dark history.

Unfortunately, it didn’t provide much comfort as they still experienced paranormal activity while swimming.


The story of Ronald Defeo and The Amityville Voices is complex. While there have been investigations into the truth behind the story, it’s difficult to say definitively whether or not any supernatural events occurred in Amityville.

There are some scientific explanations for certain aspects of the case, but no concrete evidence can prove or disprove what happened on that fateful night in 1974.

Despite this lack of proof, Ronald Defeo and The Amityville Voices remain an enduring mystery that fascinates people worldwide.